What can you do if your car insurance claim is denied?
Step 1: Get the denial and the reason in writing
Start by finding out exactly why the claim was denied. Ask the adjuster to send the decision in writing and to point to the specific part of your policy they relied on. Some states require this. The Texas Department of Insurance, for example, says that if your insurer rejects a claim, it must give you the reasons in writing.
Common reasons include:
- The insurer thinks you were at fault, or the other driver's insurer says their driver wasn't.
- The damage or injury isn't covered by your policy.
- The policy had lapsed or a driver wasn't listed.
- Late reporting, or the car was repaired before the insurer could inspect it.
Step 2: Appeal with the insurer
Most insurers will reconsider if you give them a reason. Write a short, calm letter or email that:
- Lists your claim number and the date of the denial.
- Explains why you disagree, quoting your policy language if you can.
- Includes new evidence: photos, repair estimates, medical records, a police report, or witness names.
- Asks for a supervisor or claims manager to review it.
Keep copies of everything and a log of every call with dates and names. If the other driver's insurer denied you over fault, see what to do if the other driver lies about fault.
Ask about your situation
Type your question the way you'd say it. Free, no sign-up, and we never ask for your name.
Find help near youStep 3: Use appraisal for disputes over value
If your insurer accepts the claim but you disagree about the amount, such as a low total loss value, look for an appraisal clause in your policy. Maine's Bureau of Insurance says most auto policies have one. Each side hires its own appraiser at its own cost to work out the amount. Read your policy for the exact steps.
Appraisal only works with your own insurer. A value fight with the other driver's insurer may need to go to small claims or another court.
Step 4: File a complaint with your state
Every state has an insurance department that takes consumer complaints for free. The NAIC says these departments can look into unfair claim delays or denials and failure to honor the policy. The department sends your complaint to the insurer, which must respond, and can require the company to fix problems it finds. Insurers can't retaliate against you for filing.
When you file, include your policy number, a short timeline, the policy language, and what you want to happen. Keep in mind the limits: Maine's Bureau notes it can't force an insurer to satisfy you if no insurance laws were broken.
States also have their own fair claims handling rules. Texas, for example, generally gives insurers 15 business days to decide after getting all the information they asked for, with up to 45 more days if they explain the delay.
When to talk to a lawyer
Consider a lawyer if you were hurt, the amount at stake is large, the insurer stops responding, or you think the denial was made in bad faith. Lawsuit deadlines are set by state law and keep running during an appeal, so don't wait too long. Our guide on whether you need a lawyer can help you decide. accidents.si can show lawyers and other help near your ZIP code.
Common questions
How long do I have to appeal a denied car insurance claim?
It depends on your policy and state. Act quickly, ask the insurer in writing if there is an appeal deadline, and keep track of your state's deadline to file a lawsuit.
Does it cost money to file a complaint with the insurance department?
No. State insurance departments review consumer complaints for free, and most accept them online, by mail, or by phone.
Can the insurance department make my insurer pay?
It can require an insurer to fix violations of insurance laws or the policy. It can't force payment if the insurer followed the law and the policy.
What if the other driver's insurance denied my claim?
You may be able to file under your own coverage, like collision or uninsured motorist, and let your insurer go after the other company. Small claims court is another option for smaller amounts.