Find help near you

What should I do if the other driver lies about who was at fault?

Updated October 6, 2026 · General information, not professional advice

Short answerIf the other driver lies about fault, the answer is evidence: photos, damage locations, witnesses, video and the police report. Tell your own insurer right away, give it everything you have, and consider filing under your own collision coverage so you're not waiting on the other insurer.

Why the other driver's story matters

When drivers disagree, insurers decide fault based on evidence, not on who sounds more convincing. The Texas Department of Insurance warns that if you don't have witnesses and the other driver denies fault, their insurance company might deny your claim. That's why evidence gathered early matters so much.

Evidence that shows what really happened

  • Photos of where the cars ended up and of all damage. The point of impact often contradicts a false story.
  • Independent witnesses: names and phone numbers, and a short written statement if possible.
  • Video: dashcams, doorbell cameras, traffic cameras, and store or gas station security cameras. Ask owners to save footage right away.
  • The police report: statements, diagram and any citation.
  • Phone records in a later dispute, if distracted driving is suspected.
  • Your own notes, written as soon as possible, including anything the other driver said at the scene.
  • Vehicle data: some cars record speed and braking data before a crash.

Ask about your situation

Type your question the way you'd say it. Free, no sign-up, and we never ask for your name.

Find help near you

Steps to take when fault is disputed

  1. Report it to your own insurer right away and tell them the other driver is disputing fault.
  2. Send your evidence to your insurer and the other insurer.
  3. Don't give the other insurer a recorded statement until you're ready; you aren't usually required to.
  4. Use your own collision coverage if the other insurer denies or delays. The Texas Department of Insurance says your company will probably try to collect from the other driver's company, and you'll pay your deductible.
  5. Ask about arbitration. Many insurers resolve disputes between themselves through inter-company arbitration.

How shared fault can affect your payment

If the insurers decide fault is shared, many states reduce your payment by your share. For example, if you're found 20% at fault, you might receive 80% of your damages. A few states, such as Maryland, can bar recovery entirely if you share any fault, so a disputed-fault claim there is especially important to fight with evidence.

What not to do when the other driver lies

  • Don't contact the other driver to argue or threaten. Let insurers handle it.
  • Don't exaggerate your own account to compete with theirs. Stick to facts you can support.
  • Don't post about the crash online.
  • Don't sign anything from the other insurer that admits shared fault.
  • Don't wait. Video and witnesses are easiest to find in the first few days.

When to get legal help

If you were injured and the other driver's lie is blocking your claim, a lawyer can obtain video, interview witnesses and use the legal process to get records. For car-only damage, going through your own collision coverage is often the simplest path. If you want to talk to someone, accidents.si can show injury lawyers near your ZIP code.

Common questions

What happens when both drivers blame each other and there are no witnesses?

Insurers rely on physical evidence like damage location and photos. They may split fault, or each driver's insurer may pay its own customer under collision coverage.

Can I dispute an insurance company's fault decision?

Yes. Ask for the decision and reasons in writing, send new evidence, ask for a supervisor, and file a complaint with your state insurance department if needed.

Can I report the other driver for lying?

Knowingly lying to an insurer to support a claim can be insurance fraud. You can share your concerns and evidence with the insurer and police.

Will a dashcam help if the other driver lies?

Yes. Dashcam video is often the clearest evidence of what happened. Save the original file and give a copy to your insurer.

How long does it take to resolve a disputed fault claim?

It can add weeks or months, especially if insurers go to arbitration. Using your own collision coverage can get your car fixed sooner.

Confirm with