Find help near you

Can I choose my own body shop after a car accident?

Updated October 6, 2026 · General information, not professional advice

Short answerYes. In most states you can choose your own body shop, and the insurance company can recommend a shop but cannot require you to use it. California and Texas, for example, say this directly. The insurer still only has to pay a reasonable cost for the repair.

Can the insurance company make me use their body shop?

Generally, no. Many states have anti-steering laws:

  • California: Insurance Code section 758.5 says an insurer may not require a vehicle to be repaired at a specific shop. It may suggest one only after telling you that you have the right to choose.
  • Texas: the Texas Department of Insurance says companies might give you a list of preferred shops but can't require you to use a shop on the list.

Rules differ in the details, so check with your state insurance department if an adjuster pressures you.

Insurer's shop vs. your own shop: the trade-offs

Using the insurer's preferred (direct repair) shop often means faster approval, less paperwork, and a repair warranty backed by the insurer.

Using your own shop means you pick who works on your car, which matters for newer cars with sensors and cameras, or if you want manufacturer-certified repairs. The trade-off can be more back-and-forth between the shop and the adjuster over price.

Either way, the insurer pays based on a reasonable cost to repair. If your shop charges more than the insurer considers reasonable, you may owe the difference unless the shop and adjuster agree.

Ask about your situation

Type your question the way you'd say it. Free, no sign-up, and we never ask for your name.

Find help near you

How to choose a good body shop

  • Ask whether the shop is certified by your car's manufacturer, especially for aluminum bodies or driver-assist systems.
  • Ask if they will recalibrate sensors and cameras after repairs, and whether that is in the estimate.
  • Get a written estimate and a written warranty on workmanship.
  • Ask how they handle supplements, which are added charges when hidden damage is found.
  • Read recent reviews and check for complaints with your state's consumer protection office.

accidents.si can show body shops near your ZIP code so you can compare a few.

OEM vs. aftermarket parts

Insurers are usually required to pay only for parts of "like kind and quality," not necessarily original manufacturer (OEM) parts. The Texas Department of Insurance says this plainly. Some policies and some states require notice or consent before non-OEM parts are used. If you want OEM parts, ask whether your policy covers them; if not, you may pay the difference.

If the adjuster pressures you to use their shop

Adjusters may say things like "we can't guarantee the repair" or "it will take longer" if you choose your own shop. Some of that may be true about the warranty, but it can't be used to force your choice. If you feel pressured:

  • Tell the adjuster in writing which shop you have chosen.
  • Ask them to put any limits on payment in writing, with reasons.
  • Ask your shop to deal with the adjuster directly about the estimate.
  • Contact your state insurance department if the pressure continues.

What happens when the shop finds more damage

  1. The shop documents the hidden damage with photos.
  2. It sends a supplement request to the adjuster.
  3. The adjuster approves it, sometimes after re-inspecting.
  4. Tell the adjuster about the delay so your rental can be extended.

If the insurer and your shop can't agree, ask for a supervisor, put your concerns in writing, and review your policy's appraisal clause.

Common questions

Do I have to get multiple estimates?

Usually not. Some insurers ask for one or two estimates or inspect the car themselves. Your policy explains what is required.

Who pays the body shop, me or the insurance company?

Insurers often pay the shop directly or issue a check to you and the shop, or to you and your lender. On your own collision claim, you pay your deductible to the shop.

Can I keep the insurance check and not fix my car?

If you own the car outright, often yes. If you have a loan or lease, the lender is usually named on the check and will require repairs.

Confirm with