Find help near you

Will my insurance go up after an accident I didn't cause?

Updated October 6, 2026 · General information, not professional advice

Short answerUsually not, or not by much. Insurers mainly raise rates for accidents where you were at fault, and some states restrict surcharges for not-at-fault crashes. But a not-at-fault claim can still affect discounts or your renewal price with some insurers, depending on your state's rules.

Will my insurance go up if the accident wasn't my fault?

Most insurers apply an accident surcharge when you are found mostly at fault. When the other driver caused the crash and their insurer pays, many insurers don't surcharge you. Still, practices vary by company and state, and some insurers consider overall claim frequency when pricing renewals or applying claim-free discounts.

State rules that limit rate increases

  • California: insurers must send written notice when they decide you were "principally at fault," meaning more than 51% responsible, including the percentage of fault assigned to you and the other driver. That gives you a chance to dispute it.
  • Maryland: the Maryland Insurance Administration says an uninsured motorist claim can affect your premium and discounts even if you weren't at fault, but PIP claims for medical bills or lost wages cannot be used to raise your rates.
  • Other states have their own rules on what can and cannot be surcharged. Your state insurance department can tell you yours.

Ask about your situation

Type your question the way you'd say it. Free, no sign-up, and we never ask for your name.

Find help near you

Claims that are less likely to raise your rate

  • Claims paid by the at-fault driver's insurer
  • Claims your insurer recovered in full from the other side (subrogation)
  • Hit-and-run claims where you weren't at fault, with some insurers
  • PIP or medical claims in states that bar surcharges for them

Claims that are more likely to count: at-fault collisions, and sometimes a pattern of several claims in a short time.

How to protect your rate after a not-at-fault accident

  • Gather proof of fault: photos, witnesses and the police report.
  • File with the other driver's insurer when fault is clear, or let your insurer pursue them.
  • Ask your insurer how the claim will be coded and whether it will be marked not-at-fault.
  • Dispute a fault decision in writing if you disagree, with your evidence attached.
  • Ask about accident forgiveness if your policy has it.
  • Shop around at renewal if your rate rises; insurers weigh claims differently.

How insurers decide whether an accident was your fault

Insurers look at the police report, photos, damage locations, witness statements and each driver's account. Some situations are usually treated as not your fault, such as being rear-ended while stopped, or being hit while legally parked. Others, like lane changes and intersection crashes, often involve a closer look. If your insurer finds you partly at fault, ask what percentage it assigned and why, and whether that percentage triggers a surcharge under your state's rules.

Should I still report a minor accident I didn't cause?

Usually yes. Most policies require you to report accidents promptly. If you don't, and the other driver later claims you caused it or that they were hurt, your insurer may have trouble defending you. Reporting an accident is not the same as filing a claim for payment, but ask your insurer how they treat each.

If you need repairs, accidents.si can show body shops and rental cars near your ZIP code.

Common questions

How long does an accident stay on my insurance record?

Many insurers look back three to five years, but it varies by company and state. Ask your insurer what lookback period it uses.

Can my insurer drop me after a not-at-fault accident?

States limit when insurers can cancel or refuse to renew. A single not-at-fault accident is rarely a reason, but check your state's rules.

Does filing with the other driver's insurance affect my rates?

A claim paid entirely by the at-fault driver's insurer is less likely to raise your rate, though practices vary.

What is accident forgiveness?

It is a policy feature, offered by some insurers, that prevents your first at-fault accident from raising your rate. Terms and eligibility vary by company and state.

Should I pay for minor damage myself to avoid a rate increase?

Some people do for very small at-fault damage. If you weren't at fault, the other driver's insurer should pay, and your policy may still require you to report the crash.

Confirm with